This Post is taken from our Questions Section on Jewelry Secrets that is meant to give Advice to people about Jewelry, Gemstones and Diamonds.
If you have a Question you’d like answered about Jewelry or Diamonds, as in a Particular Loose Stone, don’t Hesitate to Ask Here: Q&A :)
I’ll do everything I can to Advise you and point you in the Right Direction.
If it will Help you, it will Help others as well.
I absolutely LOVE your site! I’ve learned so, so much.
I’m considering Purchasing between 2 Pre-Owned Tiffany & Co GIA Certified Solitaires both Dated 1989.
I’ve been trying to find Cuts close to 60/60 and these are the Best that I have found:
- Carat Weight – 1.64 Ct
- Clarity – VS2
- Color – E
- Depth – 60.3
- Table – 62.164
- Girdle – Thin
- Polish/Symmetry – Very Good
- Carat Weight – 1.20 Ct
- Clarity – VVS2
- Color – D
- Depth – 59.3
- Table – 59
- Girdle – Medium
- Polish/Symmetry – Very Good
Your opinion would be greatly appreciated.
This is a Toughy! I would think Based upon the Information that they are probably close to the Same Price. One is Bigger, but having a Slightly Lower Clarity and Color than the other.
Both Diamonds are Awesome and within a Percent or two of being Ideal. I’ve never seen a Diamond hit 60/60 on the dot, so to get this close to it is Awesome and nothing that you would ever see with the naked eye.
The only thing that concerns me slightly is the Girdle on the Larger Stone. I like a Medium Girdle just because it’s more Durable and won’t Chip or Nick like a Thin or Very Thin Girdle would. But then with a Cut close to Ideal, I don’t think a Thin Girdle will be an Issue here (we’re not talking about Spread or Shallow Stones).
You can’t Lose with either Stone. Both Diamonds are Pure White and Both have Inclusions so Small you’d need a Microscope to see.
Putting the two side by side I would think they would look Pretty Identical in both Sparkle and Brilliance. So I say, go with the Bigger Stone. The Color and Clarity are still Top Notch and Awesome, and being able to Memorize the couple of Small Pin Points in the Diamond is Good Identification on your part. A VVS Diamond will be Very Hard to Spot anything inside it, which also means it will be Tough to look in a Microscope or 10x Jeweler’s Loupe and know that it’s your Stone.
Go with the VS. You get a much Bigger Stone and with it being GIA, you can’t ever go Wrong!
Here are some Examples of Stones similar in Quality and Price…
|CARAT WEIGHT, CLARITY, COLOR, CUT, CERTIFIED||PRICE||VIEW|
|1.64 CT, VS2, E, IDEAL, GIA||$24,300||VIEW|
|1.22 CT, VVS2, D, PREMIUM, GIA||$22,130||VIEW|
I’m taking your Advise for Sure!
Can’t thank you enough for the Invaluable Information on your Site.
Your Advise and time is Very Much Appreciated.
Top Recommended Vendors:
James Allen is a leader in diamonds. Their real time interactive diamond inspection is the best in the industry. View and rotate any diamond under 20x magnification. Their prices, selection, lifetime warranty, 24/7 customer support and hassle free returns are unbeatable. Visit James Allen today.
Blue Nile is the largest and most well known respected diamond dealer online. They are highly trusted, have a huge inventory, and low low prices (compare anywhere and see for yourself). If you want to save money, or build your own ring, this is the place to shop. Visit Blue Nile today.